Personal Perspectives on Vision Loss with Brian Deer

Today I'm talking with Brian Deer, who shares the same condition I have - Stargardt disease. Brian's journey has taken him from the world of manufacturing research and development to becoming a philosophy professor. He went through that frustrating experience many of us know - being told by doctor after doctor that nothing was wrong, only to finally get a diagnosis with no treatment options. From there, he made a complete career pivot: from highly technical engineering work to academia, earning a master's degree in philosophy and now teaching at the college level.

Finding Your Path: A Conversation with Brian Deer About Vision Loss, Career Changes, and Moving Forward

In my latest inSight Out podcast episode, I had the privilege of speaking with Brian Deer, a philosophy professor who shares my diagnosis of Stargardt disease. His story illuminates both the challenges and possibilities that come with progressive vision loss, offering insights that extend far beyond the low vision community.

The Long Road to Diagnosis

Brian's journey began in elementary school when routine eye exams revealed vision problems that couldn't be easily explained. What followed was a frustrating pilgrimage to approximately one hundred doctors over several years—each one unable to find anything wrong and many suggesting he was fabricating his symptoms.

The emotional toll of being repeatedly told you're lying about your own experience is profound, especially for a child. Brian described having an emotional breakdown in one doctor's office after being accused of deception once again. It was only at his final appointment, with Dr. Richard Lewis in Houston, that he received the diagnosis of Stargardt disease through a specialized dye injection test.

The diagnosis brought both relief and disappointment. While validation felt good after years of disbelief, the doctor's honest assessment was stark: there was no treatment, no cure, and nothing would change except now Brian knew what he had.

Early Adaptation Strategies

Brian's story demonstrates the gradual nature of progressive vision loss. For years after his diagnosis, his vision remained functional enough that he didn't need assistive technology or major lifestyle changes. However, he began developing coping strategies that he still uses today—like using two pieces of material butted together for precise measurements in woodworking, rather than relying on visual measurement tools.

High school brought the first real challenges. Headaches from eye strain became common as he struggled with regular textbooks, holding them closer to compensate for his vision loss. The large print textbooks available were embarrassingly huge and impractical. Perhaps more problematic was being grouped with students who had behavioral and cognitive disabilities in the special needs program, where he was treated as if he couldn't understand his own condition or develop solutions.

This experience taught him a crucial lesson that would serve him throughout life: the importance of self-advocacy. As Brian put it, doctors had told him that self-advocacy would be the most important skill he'd develop as a visually impaired person, and they were right.

The Transportation Turning Point

The most significant shift in Brian's experience came at age 24 when he gave up his driver's license. Living in the suburbs and working across town with no viable public transportation options, he faced a new level of dependency and logistical complexity that couldn't be solved through sheer determination.

He described devastating days when unreliable transportation left him stranded or when bus drivers refused to allow his electric scooter on board, forcing him to walk home after exhausting 14-hour days. These experiences highlighted a harsh reality: sometimes the systems designed to help simply fail, and there's no amount of self-advocacy that can fix every situation in the moment.

Academic Reinvention

After working in research and development in the HVAC industry—a highly technical, precise field—Brian made a dramatic career change. Using free college tuition available to legally blind individuals in his state, he pursued a master's degree in philosophy.

This transition required embracing assistive technology he had previously avoided. CCTV devices, audio books, and disability services became essential tools rather than optional accommodations. Brian discovered that slowing down his reading pace with a CCTV actually improved his comprehension—an unexpected benefit of adaptation.

One of his most significant adjustments was learning to attend lectures without taking notes. Unable to read his own handwriting, he developed the skill of focused listening and retention, becoming what he describes as more present in classroom discussions than students who were dividing their attention between writing and listening.

Teaching Philosophy with Vision Loss

Brian's work as a philosophy professor presents both ideal conditions and unique challenges. The conversational nature of philosophical discussion plays to his strengths—concepts and ideas flow naturally through dialogue. However, the extensive reading requirements and the need to grade student papers create ongoing difficulties.

A particularly modern challenge has emerged with AI technology. Brian can't easily use traditional in-class handwritten exams to combat AI-assisted cheating because he cannot read student handwriting even with assistive devices. This puts him in the position of trying to solve a disability-related problem within a larger unsolved puzzle that the entire educational system is grappling with.

Practical Wisdom for Moving Forward

When I asked Brian what advice he'd offer to someone newly diagnosed or facing major life decisions with vision loss, his response was refreshingly direct: "Just do it. If you want to do something, just start the process."

His perspective is that every obstacle will be solved one day at a time, one problem at a time. The mistake many people make is bringing all future problems into the present moment, making the challenge seem impossible. But when you break it down and face each difficulty as it actually arises, the path becomes manageable.

Brian was honest about still having bad days when everything feels futile and overwhelming. The key insight is that these feelings pass, and the work of moving forward continues.

Communicating with Family and Friends

One area Brian admits he's still developing is helping family and friends understand his experience. He's found more success by asking them not to understand his challenges but simply to believe that he's facing real difficulties. Rather than trying to convince someone to grasp the complexity of navigating the world with vision loss, he asks for trust and emotional support.

This shift from seeking understanding to requesting belief has improved his relationships and reduced the isolation that can come with feeling perpetually misunderstood.

Reflections

Brian's story reinforces several themes I encounter regularly in my work with people adjusting to vision loss. The medical system's frequent failure to believe patient experiences. The inadequacy of one-size-fits-all disability services. The crucial importance of self-advocacy. The reality that adaptation is an ongoing process, not a destination.

But perhaps most importantly, Brian's journey from R&D engineer to philosophy professor demonstrates that vision loss doesn't have to limit your aspirations or define your possibilities. Career changes, advanced education, and personal growth remain achievable—they just require different strategies and tools.

For anyone facing their own mountain of challenges, Brian's message is clear: you don't have to climb it all at once. Just take the next step, solve the next problem, and trust that the path will reveal itself as you move forward.

If you'd like to share your own experience with vision loss or suggest topics for future episodes, visit us at speakpipe.com/insightoutpod. You can find all episodes at insightoutpod.com and follow us on social media @insightoutpod.

Previous
Previous

When Blindness isn't Loss with Karen Rose LMFT

Next
Next

Understanding Guide Dogs with Gretchen Fisher Orr